How to build a Holiday Offer That Actually Gets You Leads

If you've ever run a holiday sale and thought, why did that fall flat... you're not alone. Most small business owners treat holidays like a discount day. Slap 10% off on it, post it once, and hope.

Here's the shift. A holiday promo isn't a discount. It's lead gen.

Get paid to get leads with a gift card

Here's one of my favorite plays. You sell a gift card valued at $200, but you sell it for just 20 bucks.

Let me walk you through two business owners. Karen and Susie. Same year in business, same quality of work, same client who said yes on the same Tuesday.

That's a banging deal.

and thought, perfect, I'll get something over to you.

She sat down that night and wrote it up the right way. Wanted it to look right. Wednesday was busy. Thursday morning it went out.

The catch is that the buyer has to purchase it for a specific person, or a few people, and hand over their contact info.

Now you can reach out and say,

hey John, your friend Megan bought you a $200 gift card. We'd love for you to come in and spend it.

But by Thursday morning, it wasn't the thing they were excited about on Tuesday.

It was an email. Sitting under nine other emails. A task. And tasks wait.

Think about the math.

Karen sent five follow-ups. Every single one started with 'sorry to chase.'

Susie? She handed it over while they were still nodding. Thirty seconds. Off her phone. Done.

One of them has the money. The other has a Tuesday she'll never get back.

You're giving up $180, but you got $20 and a new lead in your door. If that person buys again, you've made all your upside and now you're up money.

Use a giveaway to collect a ton of leads

First, contest rules are different in every state. Talk to a lawyer before you do this.


Here's the play. You give away something awesome, like $60,000 worth of stuff for a year. All people do is submit their contact info and why they should win.

Then you drive as much traffic as you possibly can. And you make a big public show of the winner.

Here's the magic. Only one or two people win, but you now have the contact info of everyone who entered.

You reach out to all of them and say, hey, you didn't win, but because of the holiday you can still get it for a special price.

STOP giving 10% off.

You know those pop ups that say, join our list for 10% off? That's better than nothing if someone was already going to buy.

But if you're trying to win attention from all the other businesses, you need something more dramatic.

I like 40% to 60% off the first purchase. Shoot, give the first purchase away for free if it gets you the data.

Why? Because now you can remarket through ads, emails, and SMS down the road.

Wrap it up with MAGIC

We use a simple framework called MAGIC when we build offers.

M is Magnetic. What's the wow factor?

A is Avatar. Who is this for?

G is Guarantee. What do they clearly get?

.I is Interval. How often, or when?

C is Container word. What word wraps it all up?

Here's an example

Buy one taco, get three free. For the hungry gamer sitting at his computer. On Cyber Monday. Feed your hunger. Boom. If you own a taco shop, you can go sell tacos right now.

You can use any framework you want.

This one just makes it easier to package and communicate your offer.

Wrap it up with MAGIC

We use a simple framework called MAGIC when we build offers.

M is Magnetic. What's the wow factor?

A is Avatar. Who is this for?

G is Guarantee. What do they clearly get?

.I is Interval. How often, or when?

C is Container word. What word wraps it all up?

Here's an example

Buy one taco, get three free. For the hungry gamer sitting at his computer. On Cyber Monday. Feed your hunger. Boom. If you own a taco shop, you can go sell tacos right now.

You can use any framework you want.

This one just makes it easier to package and communicate your offer.

Start early and work backwards

Don't start marketing the day of the holiday. Start three, even four weeks ahead. That gives you enough runway for people to see it and join in.

And do the math. If you want one paying customer, you'll talk to about four or five people. If you want five conversations, you need around 25 leads.

So work backward from the sales you want. That tells you how many leads you need and how much traffic to drive.

That's how you get more sales from more leads, more consistently.

Watch the full breakdown to see all of these plays in action and pick one for your next holiday, y'all.

Let's get started!

Helping small businesses scale

© 2026 ALOHA Apps is a brand of Powered By Aloha LLC.